Overcoming Fulfillment Bottlenecks: A Guide for Growing Online Businesses │ Nippon Express

Many new online businesses begin by handling their own order fulfillment because it seems easy and cheap. However, as sales volumes increase, this seemingly straightforward approach can quickly become a bottleneck, causing operational slowdowns, reduced customer satisfaction, and hindered business growth.

To decide whether to improve your in-house fulfillment or switch to a third-party logistics (3PL) provider, it's important to understand common problems and their solutions.

Phase 1: Quick Wins - Optimizing for Immediate Improvement

These are easy improvements that require little investment and give quick results.

1. Packaging Inefficiencies:

Problem:
- Excess material usage, inadequate protection, and inconsistent packaging lead to increased costs and potential damage.
Solution:
- Conduct a packaging audit to identify areas for optimization.
- Standardize box sizes and utilize void fill efficiently.
- Invest in cost-effective, protective materials.
- Implement pre-made solutions like bubble mailers for small, fragile items.
Example:
- Utilizing envelope-type bubble wrap (bubble mailers) for small, lightweight items like jewelry or CDs can save time and reduce material costs compared to traditional bubble wrap.

2. Time Consumption (Workflow Optimization):

Problem:
- Disorganized workspaces and inefficient processes lead to excessive fulfillment times.
Solution:
- Organize your workspace for optimal flow.
- Develop detailed checklists and standard operating procedures (SOPs).
- Schedule dedicated fulfillment blocks to minimize interruptions.
Example:
- Apply the Theory of Constraints (TOC) to identify and address bottlenecks.

1. Identify the constraint (e.g., packing station).
2. Maximize the efficiency of the constraint.
3. Adjust other processes to support the constraint.
4. Increase the capacity of the constraint.
5. Repeat the process for continuous improvement.

3. Inefficient Picking and Packing (Layout Optimization):

Problem:
- Disorganized inventory and inefficient warehouse layouts increase picking and packing times.
Solution:
- Redesign your warehouse layout for optimal flow.
- Implement designated packing stations.
- Organize inventory based on product popularity using FSN (Fast-Moving, Slow-Moving, Non-Moving) analysis.
Example:
- Place fast-moving items near packing stations and at easily accessible heights.*Note: FSN focuses on item movement speed, while ABC analysis prioritizes items based on value.

Phase 2: Harder Hurdles - Investments and Expertise Required

These problems need more investment and expert knowledge, which often leads businesses to think about using 3PL services.

4. Inventory Management Inaccuracies:

Problem:
- Manual inventory tracking leads to errors, stockouts, and overstocking.
Solution:
- Implement a robust inventory management system (IMS) with real-time tracking.
- Explore cloud-based warehouse management systems (WMS).

5. Shipping Delays:

Problem:
- Inefficient shipping logistics lead to delays and customer dissatisfaction.
Solution:
- Optimize carrier selection and route planning.
- Integrate shipping software for streamlined processes.
- Diversify carriers.
- Prior to sale, communicate expected volume with carriers.

6. Returns Management Complexity:

Problem:
- Poorly managed returns processes lead to increased costs and customer frustration.
Solution:
- Develop clear and concise return policies.
- Implement return management software.
- Train staff on efficient returns processing.
Example:
- Using a WMS with shopify integration to relist returned items quickly.

7. Limited Storage Space (Expansion):

Problem:
- Insufficient storage space hinders growth and efficiency.
Solution:
- Invest in vertical storage solutions (e.g., taller shelving, mezzanine floors).
- Implement just-in-time (JIT) inventory management.
- Donate excess unsellable inventory.

Phase 3: Very Difficult - Strategic Overhauls and External Solutions

These are the most complex bottlenecks, often requiring a shift to 3PL services.

8. Scalability Limitations:

Problem:
- Self-fulfillment cannot handle rapid growth, leading to operational strain.
Solution:
- Partner with a 3PL provider with robust scalability and global network.
- Explore 3PL services that focus on e-commerce scalability.

9. Increased Labor Costs:

Problem:
- Rising labor costs impact profitability.
Solution:
- Implement automation solutions.
- Adopt advanced warehouse management systems (WMS).
- Outsource fulfillment to a 3PL.

10. Technology Limitations (System Overhaul):

Problem:
- Outdated or inadequate technology hinders efficiency.
Solution:
- Invest in integrated, scalable technology solutions.
- Consider 3PL with advanced WMS that can be implemented without large upfront costs.
- Explore 3PL technology solutions that offer flexible implementation.

Conclusion

While self-fulfillment can be effective for small-scale operations, it’s important to recognize when it becomes a hindrance to growth.

As your business expands, the limitations of in-house fulfillment become more apparent. By identifying and addressing common bottlenecks, you can improve efficiency and maintain customer satisfaction.

Also read:

Need consultation on logistics and warehouse? Contact us now!